Eggnog French Toast

Jump to Recipe Rate this recipe

If you want something fancy and delicious for your Christmas morning breakfast or brunch, this Eggnog French Toast is perfect. Plated up, it looks amazing but it's actually easy to make and requires basic ingredients (Yes, I always have eggnog in the fridge in December). Plus the taste of eggnog, cinnamon, and extra nutmeg is something I can't turn down.

eggnog french toast on a plate with syrup, whipped cream and sprinkle of nutmeg

Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links, meaning I get a commission if you decide to purchase through my link, at no extra cost to you.

French toast makes for a delicious, easy weekend brunch

So I'm not really an overnight french toast casserole kinda person but give me a fancy plate piled high with eggnog-y perfect french toast, maple syrup, and whipped cream and I'll be happy. This is one sweet breakfast that I'd actually choose over a savory one (my fave), and I think it's all down to the holiday vibes of the eggnog, cinnamon, and nutmeg.

I'm a sucker for the holidays and I'm even more pleased by a pretty plate of food. Or a pretty jar, like my Eggnog Chia Pudding – it fits the bill for both.

I think this easy french toast is the perfect breakfast for Christmas because it looks so good but is easy and takes hardly any time. This eggnog french toast recipe is really simple and I hope you'll make it and love it. If you've never made french toast, I have step-by-step photos below.

Ingredients you need

Milk, eggs, vanilla extract, ground cinnamon, and a pinch of ground nutmeg for the custard. You'll also need the bread you like. I use a large, unsliced loaf of french bread. I buy the loaf of bread a few days before I need it and then let it sit for a few days to dry out a bit.

Ingredient Substitutions

Switch the eggnog out for milk for more of a classic french toast.
Use the bread that you like – something that will soak up the custard though. Brioche is a good choice for french toast.
Top with a dusting of powdered sugar.

How to make this recipe

So, how do you make French toast?

The basics of French toast are:

the custard
the bread

You'll dip the bread and then fry it until golden brown.

To make this eggnog french toast, choose a wide dish that can fit your bread slices in it. I chose my favorite brownie pan, it's big enough for three slices to fit.

Add the eggs, milk, cinnamon, nutmeg and the vanilla extract to the dish. Whisk everything really well.

process of making french toast: the bread, the custard and dipping the bread in the custard

Add the bread slices to the egg mixture, leave for a few seconds and then turn them over and soak the other side. Watch your bread here. If it's really dry, it'll soak up a lot of this custard so you'll want to only leave each slice in the custard mixture long enough to soak up a bit.

Note: The more custard the bread soaks up, the softer your french toast will be. If you want it drier and crispier don't let the bread soak up that much. For soft french toast, let the bread soak up more. The amount of custard you'll need will depend on this, so you may need to make more custard!

Heat a frying pan over medium heat. I use a non-stick pan for this. Add a bit of butter and a bit of oil. Add a slice or two of bread and cook on each side for 2-3 minutes or until golden brown.

More recipes for breakfast

Tips and Tricks

Cook over a medium heat to help ensure you burn your French toast.

Recipes FAQs

How do you dry bread for French Toast?

I just leave mine in the brown paper bag it comes it. I let it sit on the counter for a few days before making it.

Why do you use oil and butter for frying French toast?

I like to add oil to my butter because butter can burn easier.